NYPD fires officer for chokehold in Eric Garner's death


Daniel Pantaleo, the New York City police officer seen on video using a chokehold during Eric Garner’s deadly arrest five years ago, sparking mass protests, was fired by the department, the police commissioner said Monday.

An administrative judge this month recommended that Pantaleo be terminated over the July 17, 2014, confrontation as Garner was being arrested on Staten Island for selling loose, untaxed cigarettes.

- Advertisement -

Pantaleo, who has been with the NYPD since 2006, was suspended as soon as that departmental verdict was reached, in keeping with long-standing practice when there is a recommendation for firing. The 13-year veteran had been on desk duty as his case made its way through legal and administrative circles.

Download the NBC News app for breaking news and politics

Commissioner James O’Neill said Pantaleo was properly making an arrest, up to the point where he had Garner on the ground but still had a forearm on the man’s throat.

“Had I been in officer Pantaleo’s situation I may have similar mistakes,” O’Neill said. “I would have wished I had released my grip before it became a chokehold.”

New York City’s top policeman also heaped blame on Garner himself, saying he was wrong to have resisted arrest.

“Every time I watch that video I say to myself … ‘to Mr. Garner, don’t do it. Comply. Officer Pantaleo, don’t do it,'” the commissioner said.

Members of “Black Lives Matter” protest on the fifth anniversary of the death of Eric Garner in New York, on July 17, 2019.Michael McCoy / Reuters file

“I say that about the decisions made by both officer Pantaleo and Mr. Garner. But none of us can’t take back our decisions.”

O’Neill admitted that if he were still an officer in uniform — as he’d been for 34 years before taking charge of America’s biggest municipal police force — he too would be upset with this decision.

“I’ve been a cop a long time and if I was still a cop, I’d probably be mad. ‘You’re not looking out for us,’ but I am,” O’Neill said.

“It’s my responsibility as police commissioner to look out for the city and certainly to look out for New York City police officers. They took this job to make a difference. You all know the city has been transformed — had a lot of help, but it’s the cops out there right now and the thousands that have come before who that continue to make this city safe.”

Emerald Snipes Garner, one of Eric Garner’s daughter, thanked the family’s supporters and Commissioner O’Neill for his decision on Monday.

“Commissioner O’Neill, I thank you for doing the right thing,” the daughter told reporters during a press conference at the Harlem headquarters of the National Action Network. “I truly, sincerely thank you for firing the officer, regardless of how however you came up to your decision.”

Garner’s loved ones and NAN’s founder, the Rev. Al Sharpton, who is also an MSNBC host, said they’ll push lawmakers to make the chokehold illegal, and not just a violation of any individual department’s internal policy.

“We can’t talk about what happened in the past. We can only talk what we’re going to do” now, Emerald Snipes Garner, said.

And while O’Neill said he found fault in Garner’s actions, Emerald Snipes Garner said she had a different take: “When I watch the video, I see my father being killed.”

Pantaleo’s termination seemed to be in the cards for weeks.

The NYPD’s No. 2 official, First Deputy Commissioner Benjamin Tucker, accepted the judge’s ruling that Pantaleo should be fired, two law enforcement officials familiar with the case told NBC New York last week.

Tucker reviewed the findings and had passed them on to Commissioner O’Neill for his final review, sources said. Tucker reportedly found no new evidence to reverse the judge’s decision.

The New York Civil Liberties Union fell well short of praising O’Neill’s ruling.

“The NYPD just announced that they have fired Daniel Pantaleo, the police officer who put Eric Garner in a fatal chokehold five years ago,” according to a statement by group.

“It may be tempting to call this justice, but it’s not. We cannot lower our standards just because the NYPD has kept the bar so low.”

There are still civil avenues for Pantaleo to get his job back. And if the termination stands, Pantaleo would still be entitled to all pension benefits he had accrued through Monday, according to O’Neill.

Patrick J. Lynch, president of the city’s Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association, warned O’Neill that Pantaleo’s termination would be a morale blow to his members.

Minutes after the police commissioner announced his ruling on Monday, Lynch said O’Neill has permanently lost the confidence of officers on the beat.

“The NYPD will remain rudderless and frozen and Commissioner O’Neill will never be able to bring it back,” Lynch said in a prepared statement.

“Now it is time for every police officer in this city to make their own choice. We are urging all New York City police officer to proceed with the utmost caution in this new reality, in which they may be deemed ‘reckless’ just for doing their job. We will uphold our oath, but we cannot and will not do so by needlessly jeopardizing our careers or personal safety.”

A Staten Island grand jury declined to indict Pantaleo and, earlier this summer, the Justice Department said it would not bring federal civil rights or criminal charges against the NYPD officer.

Pantaleo was among two officers who were initially confronting Garner, 43, about his alleged sale of cigarettes in an incident captured on bystander Ramsey Orta’s cellphone.

As back-up arrived, Pantaleo jumped on Garner’s back, wrapped his left forearm around the suspect’s neck and rode him to the pavement.

New York City Police Commissioner James O’Neill pauses during a press conference to announce the termination of officer Daniel Pantaleo on Aug. 19, 2019.Drew Angerer / Getty Images

Four other officers came to assist Pantaleo, as he shoved Garner’s face into the sidewalk, all while the 6-foot-2, roughly 400-pound man repeatedly pleaded: “I can’t breathe.”

The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of New York ruled Garner’s death a homicide based on compression of his neck and chest. Though the forensic investigators also said Garner’s acute and chronic bronchial asthma, obesity and heart disease were contributing factors.

About five months after Garner’s death, a Staten Island grand jury declined to indict Pantaleo based on the evidence presented by the office of then-District Attorney Dan Donovan.

The borough’s top prosecutor, Donovan, insisted he presented all the evidence — though transcripts of grand jury proceedings have never been released.

Earlier this summer, federal prosecutors ended their five-year-long probe of the matter and elected not to pursue any civil rights charges against Pantaleo. Attorney General William Barr made the final decision not to charge Pantaleo, choosing to follow recommendations of Brooklyn prosecutors, a senior Justice Department official told NBC News in July.

At Pantaleo’s departmental trial, his defense insisted the officer did not employ a chokehold, which is banned by the NYPD. Instead, Pantaleo’s defense argued he was using “seatbelt” move, wrapping arms around a suspect’s shoulders to bring an arrest.

“I can’t breathe” became a rallying call for protests that summer by Black Lives Matter activists.

Garner’s death came less than a month before Michael Brown, an unarmed 18-year-old African American man, was fatally shot by police Officer Darren Wilson in Ferguson, Missouri.

Garner and Brown’s deaths became flashpoints for coast-to-coast protests against police brutality and systemic racism. Staffers working for members of the Congressional Black Caucus staged a walkout on Dec. 11, 2014, in protest of Garner and Brown’s deaths — and the lack of local prosecution of the police officers involved.